
The Holosun 507COMP vs 507C decision comes down to window size and how you plan to carry the gun. The 507COMP has a 1.1 x 0.87 in. competition window and a Performance Reticle System (PRS) with 8, 20, and 32 MOA circle options. The 507C has a smaller standard window, a 2 MOA dot with a 32 MOA circle, and Solar Failsafe backup power. Both use the RMR footprint, so either one bolts to a slide cut for an RMR.
Buy the 507COMP for a full-size range, competition, or home-defense pistol where the bigger window helps you find the dot faster and a larger holster is no problem. Buy the 507C for a pistol you carry every day: its smaller, lighter body works with more holsters, and solar backup is useful on a gun that rides in a holster all day.
| Spec | Holosun 507COMP | Holosun 507C (X2 and X3) |
|---|---|---|
| Footprint | RMR | RMR |
| Window size | 1.1 x 0.87 in. | X2: 0.91 x 0.63 in. X3: 0.91 x 0.67 in. |
| Reticle system | PRS: 2 MOA dot with 8, 20, or 32 MOA circle options | MRS: 2 MOA dot, 32 MOA circle, or both |
| Body dimensions | 1.8 x 1.3 x 1.3 in. | X2: 1.78 x 1.15 x 1.15 in. X3: 1.78 x 1.31 x 1.1 in. |
| Weight | 1.7 oz | X2: 1.5 oz X3: 1.55 oz |
| Battery | CR1632, side tray | CR1632, side tray |
| Solar Failsafe | No | Yes |
| Shake Awake | Yes | Yes |
| Brightness settings | 8 daylight, 4 night vision | X2: 10 daylight, 2 night vision X3: 8 daylight, 4 night vision |
| Housing | 7075-T6 aluminum | 7075-T6 aluminum |
| Waterproof rating | IP67 | IP67 |
Holosun 507COMP vs 507C: Window Size and Sight Picture
Window size is the main difference between the 507C and the 507 COMP. The 507COMP window measures 1.1 x 0.87 in. The 507C X2 measures 0.91 x 0.63 in., and the 507C X3 measures 0.91 x 0.67 in. Multiply it out, and the 507COMP gives you roughly 1.6 to 1.7 times the glass area of either 507C.
A bigger window makes it easier to pick up the dot when your presentation is a little off, and it gives you more room to track the dot through recoil and between targets. That is why Holosun built the COMP for competition. The 507C window is still plenty for most carry and defensive shooting; the 507COMP simply gives you more margin for error.
Reticle Differences: PRS vs MRS
Both optics start with a 2 MOA dot. The 507C uses Holosun’s Multi-Reticle System (MRS): a 2 MOA dot, a 32 MOA circle, or the circle and dot together. The 507COMP uses the Performance Reticle System, which pairs the 2 MOA dot with a choice of 8, 20, or 32 MOA circles.
Those extra circle sizes are the real gain. An 8 MOA circle frames the dot without covering much of the target, a 20 MOA circle is a middle ground, and the 32 MOA circle gives you the same big, fast reference the 507C offers. If you already like the 507C’s circle-dot, the 507COMP gives you that same picture plus two more options. If you only ever run the dot, the reticle difference will not matter much.
Footprint, Size, and Holster Fit
Both optics use the RMR footprint, so the 507COMP and 507C share the same mounting pattern. If you are unsure what your slide is cut for, our guide to Holosun optic footprints explains RMR, K, and 509T.
The housing is where they part ways. The 507COMP body measures 1.8 x 1.3 x 1.3 in. and weighs 1.7 oz. The 507C X2 measures 1.78 x 1.15 x 1.15 in. and weighs 1.5 oz, and the 507C X3 measures 1.78 x 1.31 x 1.1 in. and weighs 1.55 oz. The weight difference is small, but the COMP’s larger housing is easy to see on a slide.
Holster fit is the practical catch. A holster cut for a 507C may not clear the bigger 507COMP, so check your holster maker’s optic list before you buy. On a compact or slim carry pistol, the COMP can also look and feel oversized. It makes the most sense on a full-size or competition pistol.
Battery, Solar Failsafe, and 507C X2 vs X3
Both optics use a CR1632 battery in a side tray, so you can change the battery without pulling the optic off the slide. Both have Shake Awake, which powers the reticle down when the gun sits still and wakes it when it moves, along with manual brightness, memory, and lockout mode.
The 507C adds Solar Failsafe, which gives it a solar power source in addition to the battery. The 507COMP has no solar power. On a range or match gun you handle often, that is easy to live with. On a carry gun, solar backup is a nice extra margin.
If you are comparing the 507C X2 vs 507COMP or the 507C X3 vs 507COMP, the COMP’s window is larger than either generation. The X3 brings a reinforced 7075-T6 aluminum housing, a slightly larger 0.91 x 0.67 in. window, and 8 daylight and 4 night vision brightness settings, the same split the 507COMP uses. The X2 has 10 daylight and 2 night vision settings.
Other Matchups: 507K, 407C, and Ronin 507COMP
Holosun 507COMP vs 507K
The 507K and 507COMP are built for very different pistols. The 507K X2 uses Holosun’s K footprint, weighs 1 oz, and has a 0.58 x 0.77 in. window. The 507COMP uses the RMR footprint, weighs 1.7 oz, and has a 1.1 x 0.87 in. window. Because the footprints differ, the cut on your slide usually settles it: the 507K is built for slimline and micro-compact carry pistols, and the 507COMP is built for full-size and competition guns. Both pair a 2 MOA dot with a selectable circle reticle, but the 507K offers only the 32 MOA circle.
Holosun 407C vs 507COMP
The 407C is a dot-only optic: a 2 MOA dot with Solar Failsafe, in the same standard window size as the 507C. Compared with the 507COMP, you give up the large window and the circle reticles, but you get a smaller, lighter housing and solar backup. For the 407C against the standard 507C, see our 407C vs 507C comparison.
If you searched for “Holosun 407 vs 507 COMP” and meant the Holosun 407COMP, that model has the same 1.1 x 0.87 in. window as the 507COMP with a fixed 6 MOA dot instead of selectable circles. Our 507COMP vs 407COMP breakdown covers that matchup in detail.
Ronin 507COMP vs Standard 507COMP
The Holosun Ronin 507COMP was developed with Ronin Tactics. Its 1.1 x 0.87 in. window, RMR footprint, CR1632 side tray, body dimensions, and 1.7 oz weight match the standard 507COMP, so the window and fit comparisons above apply to both. Our Holosun Ronin optics guide covers the rest of the Ronin lineup.
Which Should You Buy?
- Buy the Holosun 507COMP for a full-size, competition, or range pistol when you want the bigger window and 8, 20, and 32 MOA circle options.
- Buy the Holosun 507C X3 for a carry pistol when you want a standard-size optic with Solar Failsafe and the newer reinforced housing.
- Buy the Holosun 507C X2 when you want a standard-window 507C with solar backup and 10 daylight brightness settings.
- Look at the 507K instead if your slide is cut for the K footprint.
If you are torn between the two on a full-size gun you also carry, let your holster decide. If it accepts the 507COMP, the bigger window is worth having. If it does not, the 507C gives up very little.
Shop Holosun 507COMP and 507C Optics
We carry the 507COMP in red, green, and gold, plus the Ronin edition, and the 507C in both X2 and X3 versions. Browse the collections for every color, or go straight to a model below. For more choices, see all Holosun pistol red dots or the full Holosun lineup.
- Holosun 507COMP and competition optics
- Holosun 507C sights
- Holosun 507K sights
- Holosun 507COMP Red Dot Sight, PRS Reticle
- Holosun 507COMP Green Dot Sight, PRS Reticle
- Holosun 507COMP Gold Dot Sight, PRS Reticle
- Holosun 507C X3 Green Dot Sight
Related Comparisons
FAQ
The 507COMP has a larger 1.1 x 0.87 in. window and 8, 20, and 32 MOA circle options. The 507C has a smaller standard window, a 2 MOA dot with a 32 MOA circle, and Solar Failsafe. Both use the RMR footprint.
Yes. Both mount to the RMR footprint. The 507COMP has a larger housing, so check holster fit before you switch.
It is better for competition and range guns because of its larger window and extra circle sizes. The 507C X3 is the better carry choice thanks to its smaller, lighter housing and Solar Failsafe.
Your slide cut decides it. The 507K uses the K footprint for slimline carry pistols, while the 507COMP uses the RMR footprint for full-size and competition pistols. See the 507K collection for compact options.
The 407C is a dot-only optic with a 2 MOA dot, a standard window, and Solar Failsafe. The 407COMP shares the 507COMP’s 1.1 x 0.87 in. window but uses a fixed 6 MOA dot; our 507COMP vs 407COMP comparison covers it in detail.
The Ronin 507COMP was developed with Ronin Tactics. Its window, RMR footprint, side battery tray, body size, and weight match the standard 507COMP.

Leave a Reply