Home » Blog » Firearms » Savage » Savage Stance and Savage 1911 Review

Savage Stance and Savage 1911 Review

Savage 1911 review

This Savage 1911 review covers two very different pistols from Savage Arms: the 1911 Government, a steel 1911 in .45 ACP and 9mm, and the Stance XR, a striker-fired 9mm with a removable chassis. We have not range-tested either one, so this is a look at the design, the features Savage lists, and who each pistol suits.

The short version: choose the 1911 Government if you want the classic 1911 layout with a forged stainless frame and a 5-inch barrel, and choose a Stance XR if you want a striker-fired 9mm with a built-in optics plate. Both are on our Savage pistols page, along with the 110 PCS bolt-action pistol.

PistolCaliberBarrelFeatures Savage lists
1911 Government.45 ACP or 9mm5-inchForged stainless frame and slide, dual recoil spring, VZ G10 grips
Stance9mm3.2-inchStriker-fired, black nitride slide, interchangeable backstraps
Stance XR9mm3.2-inchStance features plus an optics plate, a takedown lever, and a 13-round magazine
110 PCS.300 Blackout or 6.5 Creedmoor10.5-inch, threadedBolt action in an aluminum chassis, user-adjustable AccuTrigger

Savage 1911 Review: The 1911 Government

The 1911 Government follows the classic 1911 pattern, built by Savage with a forged stainless steel frame and slide and a 5-inch billet stainless barrel with an 11-degree crown. The barrel has a 1:16 twist, and Savage lists a dual recoil spring.

On the controls, Savage lists an ambidextrous slide lock safety. The grips are VZ G10, and the rear sight is a Novak Lo-Mount. Because sight details can differ from one model to the next, check the product page for the exact pistol you are considering. The .45 ACP versions come with two 8-round magazines.

The practical differences between the versions are finish, rail, and caliber. The stainless steel 1911 in .45 ACP is the base version. The black 1911 with an accessory rail and the stainless version with a rail add a rail, and Savage marks those models “with rail” in the name. Savage also lists the 1911 Government in 9mm with a 5-inch barrel, in black, stainless, and black-and-stainless finishes.

Who it suits: shooters who like the 1911 layout and its manual controls and want a steel pistol with a 5-inch barrel. A 1911 is a different kind of pistol from a striker-fired one, so it is worth handling both styles before you decide.

If you are choosing between calibers, the .45 ACP versions are the ones Savage describes in the most detail, with two 8-round magazines in the box. The 9mm 1911 Government has the same 5-inch barrel, so the choice comes down to the cartridge you prefer to shoot and the ammunition you plan to buy. Check the individual product page for magazine details on the 9mm models.

Savage Stance 9mm Review

The Stance is Savage’s striker-fired 9mm. It has a 3.2-inch stainless barrel with a 1:10 twist and a black nitride steel slide. The controls are ambidextrous, the backstraps are interchangeable so you can change the grip size, and the pistol is built around a removable chassis. It comes with two magazines and a hard case.

Magazine capacity for the standard Stance and the Stance MC9 differs from one listing to the next, so check the product page for the exact model before you rely on a number. If capacity is the deciding factor, look at the Stance XR, which uses a 13-round magazine.

Sights vary by version. Where a listing says 3-dot, that is the sight setup, and some versions carry night sights instead. Choosing sights is mostly a matter of how you plan to use the pistol, so read the title of the version you want.

Savage Stance XR Review: What the XR Adds

The Stance XR keeps everything above and adds three things: an optics plate for mounting a red dot, a takedown lever, and a 13-round magazine. It comes with one 13-round and one 10-round magazine. The night-sight versions use XS tritium sights. Savage also lists a Stance XR XP, which comes with a Crimson Trace red dot sight.

These are the XR versions we carry, so you can pick by sights, safety, and finish:

The standard XR does not include a red dot, so plan to choose an optic that fits the plate if you want one. Savage’s maker pages are the place to confirm which footprints the plate accepts.

How to Read the Stance Versions We List

Stance titles pack a lot into a few words, and each part tells you something. The finish comes first: black nitride, gray, or FDE. After that, a listing may say 3-dot sights or night sights, and it may say manual safety. If it does not mention a manual safety, do not assume one. The caliber is 9mm on every Stance, and the barrel is 3.2 inches, so those two details never change between versions.

That leaves three choices. First, decide whether you want a manual safety. Second, decide between 3-dot sights and night sights. Third, pick a finish. Because the XR adds the optics plate and the larger magazine, it is a natural version to compare first, and the Stance MC9 and Stance XR XP are the other names you will see on Savage’s pages.

Which Savage Pistol Fits You?

The Stance XR suits a shooter who wants a striker-fired 9mm, a choice of grip size, and the option of a red dot. The 1911 Government suits a shooter who likes the traditional steel 1911, whether in .45 ACP or 9mm. Neither design is better in the abstract. Handle both, notice which controls and grip feel natural, and let that decide.

The third Savage handgun, the 110 PCS, is not a semi-auto at all. It puts a Model 110 action in a one-piece aluminum chassis with a 10.5-inch threaded barrel, a 7-inch M-LOK forend, and a user-adjustable AccuTrigger. It takes a 10-round AICS magazine and accepts AR-15 pistol grips. We list the 110 PCS in .300 Blackout and the 110 PCS in 6.5 Creedmoor. To see how the rifles built on the same action differ, our Savage rifle models guide explains the lineup, and the Savage 110 page lists the rifles.

Questions to Ask Before You Choose

  • Do you want a manual safety? Many 1911 shooters do, and the Stance XR comes both with and without one.
  • Will you add a red dot? If so, the Stance XR is the Savage 9mm with the optics plate.
  • Which cartridge do you want? The 1911 Government comes in .45 ACP and 9mm, while the Stance is a 9mm only.
  • How do you want the pistol to feel in hand? The Stance has interchangeable backstraps, and the 1911 uses VZ G10 grips.
  • Do you want a handgun at all, or a pistol-format bolt action? The 110 PCS is a bolt-action pistol, so it handles very differently from either semi-auto.

None of these has a wrong answer. They are the questions a counter conversation usually covers, and each one narrows the list quickly.

Shop Savage Pistols

Every Savage pistol we list is on one page. Browse the full collection below, or see the rest of the lineup on the Savage Arms page.

Related Comparisons

FAQ

What calibers does the Savage 1911 come in?

Savage lists the 1911 Government in .45 ACP and 9mm, both with a 5-inch barrel. The .45 ACP versions come with two 8-round magazines.

Does the Savage 1911 have a rail?

Some versions do. Models with “with rail” in the name have an accessory rail, and the others do not.

What is the Savage Stance XR?

It is a striker-fired 9mm pistol with a 3.2-inch barrel. Compared with the standard Stance, it adds an optics plate for a red dot, a takedown lever, and a 13-round magazine.

What is the difference between the Savage Stance and Stance XR?

The XR adds the optics plate, the takedown lever, and a 13-round magazine. Both share the 3.2-inch stainless barrel, the black nitride slide, and the interchangeable backstraps.

Does the Savage Stance have night sights?

Some Stance XR versions do. Savage lists XS tritium night sights on the night-sight models, while other versions are listed with 3-dot sights.

Is the Savage Stance striker-fired?

Yes. The Stance and Stance XR are striker-fired 9mm pistols with a removable chassis and ambidextrous controls.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *